15 Tips on Handling Employee Complaints
Complaints From Employees
If you are in a position of authority, you will receive complaints from the employees that work under you. The complaints will range from something very minor in nature, to something very serious. It's up to a supervisor to figure out if the complaint is legitimate and how to respond to it.
It's not that easy though. Mishandling a complaint can have future and dire consequences. As a supervisor, there are steps you must take to protect yourself, the employee making the complaint, and those affected by the complaint if it's about another person.
This article will cover what you need to do as a supervisor when you receive a complaint from an employee.
Types of Employee Complaints
Issues With Co-Workers
Lack of Vacation/Sick Leave
Who, What, When, Where, Why, and How
When asking questions about an employee complaint, ensure you cover each of the following to get as many details as possible:
- Who - Who is this incident about? Who was involved? Who knows about it? Who witnessed it?
- What - What happened? What were you doing at the time of the incident? What caused the incident? What proof can you provide this incident happened?
- When - When did the incident take place? When else could this have happened?
- Where - Where did this incident take place? Where else could this have happened? Where exactly were you at the time of the incident?
- Why - Why did it happen? Why did you come forward with this complaint? Why did you think the incident happened?
- How - How are you feeling after this incident? How has this incident affected others? How can I help you?
Receiving Employee Complaints
Receiving an employee complaint is the start of the process, and can be the most critical one as the complaint will dictate how you will react. Do the following when receiving an employee complaint:
- Listen to the complaint fully. Even if you know it's a frivolous complaint, listen to the complaint completely. This will allow the employee to feel like their voice is heard. In some cases they don't want any action at all, they just want their voice heard.
- Ask lots of questions. During the conversation, ask a lot of questions about the incident. Always remember: "Who, what, when, where, why, and how." You can also rephrase some information given to you and ask if it's correct, to ensure you understand it fully. Questions are a great way to ensure the information is accurate and you don't receive any inconsistent details.
- Ask for something in writing. This is a very critical piece of the complaint process. After your conversation, request that the person submit something in an e-mail, memo, etc. outlining the facts of the complaint. If something arises due to the complaint, you have the written documentation as proof as to what was said.
- Advise the person to keep the complaint to themselves. Employees love nothing more than to gossip, but when it comes to a complaint, they must keep it to themselves. In turn, as a supervisor, you need to keep the complaint to yourself and on a strictly need to know basis.
- Advise the person making the complaint you will look into it. Don't make any further comments, like what you plan to do in regards to their complaint. Just thank the employee for the information and state you will look into the matter.
How NOT to Handle Employee Complaints
Don't Waste Time in Handling Employee Complaints
Time is of the essence when handling employee complaints. The longer you take to address the complaint, the easier it will be for people to forget details, for another mishap to happening resulting in another complaint, etc. I have seen things go from bad to worse because supervisors did not address complaints right away.
Investigating Employee Complaints
Once you receive a complaint, you have to investigate it accordingly. Depending on the complaint, there could be various ways to investigate it, but it should generally be the same each time.
- If there were witnesses to the incident, then talk to all of them. Ask questions along the lines of "who, what, when, where, why, and how". Share as little details with them as possible. This ensures they provide the information in their own words and you won't be accused of leading them.
- Obtain all relevant documentation. If there are documents, files, computer information, etc. related to the complaint, gather that information to hold in your care. Any evidence to the incident will help you as you address the complaint.
- Look through all of the evidence. While there could be overwhelming evidence that the incident is true, there could be one piece of evidence that turns everything around. Don't just take the person's word for it, look into everything.
- Talk to the person who made the original complaint again. Once you receive more information and have reviewed the details, ask follow-up questions to the person making complaint just in case they forgot any details or to receive clarification if there are any discrepancies.
- Talk to your supervisor. Most times you will need the advice of your supervisor on how to handle a complaint. Present the evidence and your conclusion, and decide what action you wish to take in regards to the complaint. Alternatively, you could look into your organization's policy to see how complaints are handled. In some cases you may go to your human resources department.
Many people are never happier than when they get the opportunity to complain, while others are deeply unhappy with how things are but just accept the fact. Complaint occurs when we refuse to accept that things are wrong and we do something about it, even if that something is simply articulating our unease.— Julian Baggini
Biggest Complaint From an Employee?
What is the biggest complaint you have received from an employee?
Responding to Employee Complaints
There are various steps that must be taken when you are finally get to the point of addressing an employee complaint, such as:
- Take the appropriate action regarding the complaint. If someone needs to be written up, then write them up. If a policy change needs to be implemented, then implement it. The action should be done as quickly as possible so there won't be any future complaints about that issue.
- Advise the person making the complaint that the issue was resolved. If the complaint was against another person, then don't go into any details, just state it was resolved. If it was a procedural issue, or other issue not involving someone directly, you can advise how it was resolved.
- If the complaint was unfounded, then advise the person making the complaint of that. This will allow the employee to know what to do in the future if similar situations arise. Don't make them feel bad about the complaint, try to turn it into a learning experience.
- Move on. Once the complaint has been handled and the issue addressed, move on. Don't dwell on the issue, that could just make things worse in the long run. However...
- Keep the complaint in the back of your mind. You'll want to be able to refer to the complaint just in case another situation happens in the future. If you see a pattern of the same complaint or the same person making another complaint, you may see another issue that needs to be addressed.
So what do you do to address employee complaints? Let me know in the comments below.
This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.
Questions & Answers
How do you handle an employee who constantly criticizes another employees work?
Advise the employee they need to be concerned about their own work, and not someone else's work. If they see an issue, they can report it to their supervisor, but they shouldn't address it themselves.Helpful 15
How many hours of overtime can an employee work?
It depends on the laws in whatever particular country. There is no set limit in the United States, for example, but it is required that all hours beyond 40 are paid in overtime. Some places require a minimum of eight hours off between shifts as well, though some may choose to work.
I recommend looking at the laws in your country/state/region to figure that out. However, you can be required to work overtime and may be terminated if you refuse.Helpful 8
What do you do about a manager who talks negatively about employees, to other employees (via text)?
It's touchy. You can talk to your boss about it, or go to your boss's boss about it, but even then it would be your word against theirs. If you have an HR department, that could be your best bet. Otherwise, you could try to ignore it. But I can tell you right now that managers complain about their employees a lot, though they shouldn't to other employees.Helpful 6
What do I do when a co-worker shares private information?
What kind of information? Unfortunately, if you share something with a co-worker, the trust isn't always there. Talk to your supervisor about it.Helpful 4
What to do when employees complain that another supervisor/manager is allowing an employee on his/her shift to "make their own schedule". The claim is that hours are adjusted heavily and the employee rarely works a full shift?
In situations where an employee complains about another, I say I will investigate it (which I do) and advise it will be handled. I rarely, if ever, provide the results of the investigation.
There could be reasons behind the adjusted hours. There could be a medical reason, personal reason, etc., which the employee is allowed to do. It could be favoritism, yes, but not much can be done about that without someone else higher than that manager stepping in.
Personally, I've had employees work flexible schedules and I even do so in order to get the job accomplished. It's not an uncommon thing.Helpful 2
© 2013 David Livermore