Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) & Activity List to Project Success

WBS and Activity List: Is There a Difference?

Many project managers do not know the difference between a Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) and an Activity List. On small projects, the difference doesn't matter much. But, as things get more complicated, it's crucial to understand the difference, and to do a good job creating each one.

WBS and Activity List: What's the Difference?

Many project managers use the terms Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) and Activity List interchangeably. This is okay on small, simple projects. But it can get us into a lot of trouble as we become responsible for larger and more complicated projects, especially ones that involve teams with special skills or use sub-contractors.

Here's the confusing way of saying it:

  • A WBS is a list of what we are making.
  • An Activity List is a list of what we are doing.

Think this way, and they sound pretty much the same . . . and you're headed for trouble.
So let's think about it differently.

  • A WBS is a list of the components of the deliverable.
  • An Activity List is a list of the activities we will engage in during the project.

Now they sound quite different. We need both, and the right order is: Make the Work Breakdown Structure first, and make the Activity List second.

How Important is it to Separate the WBS From the Activity List?

I once straightened out a $10 million project that had already wasted $600,000 and was going nowhere for six months. They hadn't made a separate activity list from their WBS, and everyone was doing the wrong job. I worked with the team for just two weeks, and we straightened it all out. Once team members were thinking through their own work and making their own Activity Lists, everything got clear and straight, and the project was back on track.

Think of a Dinner Menu . . .

Imagine you are a caterer, and you are making a list of items that will be served at a prearranged dinner with no special orders. You might have a list like this:

  • Seafood bisque
  • Caesar salad
  • Chicken marsala
  • Sauteed mixed vegetables
  • Pasta
  • Tiramisu

Lovely! And what you see above is the Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) of this dinner. The activity list would be look like this:

  • the shopping plan - what stores to go to, and what to buy at each store
  • the recipes for each item, with cooking instructions
  • the work of plating, serving, and cleaning up afterwards

A WBS lists items; an activity list describes processes.

When Do We Make the WBS and the Activity List?

The creation of the Work Breakdown Structure and the Activity List are a turning point in project planning. The WBS is created as the finest level detail of defined project scope, after progressive elaboration. It completes our work on scope planning, and prepares us to plan all eight other areas of project management, including time. And the first step in detailed time and cost estimation is the creation of the Activity List. The Activity list must be prepared so that we can create our PERT chart.

A good WBS makes the transition from scope planning to time planning easy. Once we know clearly what we are making, it is easy to plan how we will make it.

Who makes the WBS and the Activity List?

Between the WBS and the Activity List, there is a big shift in who is working on the project. Creating a WBS calls for a lot of customer input. Customer communication is performed or coordinated by the project manager. And the work of building the WBS is done primarily by the project manager or by designers who know how to elicit customer requirements.

In contrast, the Activity List is best prepared by the actual workers who will be doing the work. If they describe how they will do their own work, then the Activity List is more accurate. More importantly, guided by the project manager, the team can find very efficient ways to work quickly and prevent problems. Teams who plan their own work and are self-managed create great stuff at low cost. As team members prepare the activity list, they get highly motivated and focused, so the project is on its way to success.

In construction, the WBS is made by the architect or an architectural designer on his team. Then the general contractor will check and modify the WBS, and, working with the actual construction foremen, develop the Activity List.

In computer programming these days, we often have programmer-analysts who do both design and application development. In that case, the person doing the work does not change. But the role does change. If you do this type of work - and I do - it is a good idea to picture yourself changing hats. Put on one hat to listen to customers and do design, and a different hat to be alone and plan the activities of your work.

My Utility Shelf

The set of utility shelves I built using the WBS and one of the activity lists in this article.
The set of utility shelves I built using the WBS and one of the activity lists in this article. | Source

A Case Study: Building a Utility Shelf

This case study should make the difference between a Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) and an activity list completely clear.

I built a set of utility shelves in my laundry room. There are three shelves on one wall, each 3 feet long. Here is the WBS:

Utility Shelves Work Breakdown Structure

3 wood shelves, 3' x 8" x 3/4"
6 braces, 9" long, two to hold each shelf
2 adjustable wall mounts to hold the braces
6 screws to bolt shelves to the wall
6 anchors to hold screws into the wall

The photo to the left shows you what the shelves look like, by the way.

Three Possible Activity Lists for One Project

To show you how different an activity list is from a WBS, I'm going to create three different activity lists, each of which uses the same WBS to create the same set of shelves:

  • The D-I-Y (do it yourself) list can be done by someone with carpentry skills.
  • The home repair hobbyist does it himself, but doesn't do carpentry.
  • The hire a professional solution looks quite different!

Activity List #1: The Do-It-Yourself (D-I-Y) Approach

  1. Buy anchors, screws, wall mounts, and braces.
  2. Buy two 8' x 8" x 3/4" pine shelving boards and walnut stain
  3. Cut three 3' shelves from the boards.
  4. Stain the boards, and let them dry.
  5. Measure locations in the wall for the wall mounts.
  6. Mark locations of the screw holes.
  7. Check screw hole locations with a level.
  8. Drill 6 holes, and place 6 anchors in walls.
  9. Mount 2 adjustable wall mounts with 6 screws, screws set loosely.
  10. Tighten all screws.
  11. Attach braces to wall mounts.
  12. Check braces with a level.
  13. Place shelves on braces.
  14. Clean up.

Activity List #2: The Home-Repair Hobbyist Approach

  1. Buy all items on the to-do list, including pre-cut, pre-stained shelves.
  2. Measure locations in the wall for the wall mounts.
  3. Mark locations of the screw holes.
  4. Check screw hole locations with a level.
  5. Drill 6 holes, and place 6 anchors in walls.
  6. Mount 2 adjustable wall mounts with 6 screws, screws set loosely.
  7. Tighten all screws.
  8. Attach braces to wall mounts.
  9. Check braces with a level.
  10. Place shelves on braces.
  11. Clean up.

Activity List #3: The Hire a Professional Solution

  1. Buy all items on the to-do list, including pre-cut, pre-stained shelves.
  2. Hire a handyman to install the shelves and clean up after himself.
  3. Pay the handyman.

Three Different Activity Lists for One WBS

As the old saying goes, there's more than one way to skin a cat. You see above three different ways of doing the same project; three different activity lists. And you can see that each one would have a different schedule and a different budget, as well.

WBS and Activity List

Before you read this article, did you know the difference between a WBS and an activity list? Choose the answer closest to true for you.

  • I'd never heard of either one. It's all rocket science to me.
  • I'd heard of a WBS, but not an activity list.
  • I've made to-do lists, punch lists, and activity lists, but never worried about a WBS.
  • I'm an old hand, I was already familiar with both.
See results without voting

Keep Your WBS and Your Activity List Straight

So, the lesson is: Keep your WBS and your activity list separate, and keep them straight.

On a small project, especially if you're doing all the work, you can run them together.

But on a project with a team, or a project where there might be different approaches worth considering, do the WBS first, and then work out the activity list. And if you can, have the team build their own activity list.

More by this Author

Comments 8 comments

leahlefler profile image

leahlefler 4 years ago from Western New York

I love your use of a dinner menu to explain a work breakdown structure vs. activity plan, Sid. I am not familiar with many of the terms, and this was a clear example that helped me to understand the concepts! Your shelf building example is excellent, too - for large-scale projects, it is essential to understand the difference!

Robert Erich profile image

Robert Erich 4 years ago from California

This is a great article! Although I think you are speaking from more of an engineering perspective, I have had experience with this type of thinking when working with programmers to develop a website. It is essential to know the difference between what is being created and what needs to be done to get that created.

I love your analogy using the utility shelf. Certainly helps to break it down!

Great article! Keep up the good writing.

SidKemp profile image

SidKemp 4 years ago from Boca Raton, Florida (near Miami and Palm Beach) Author

Thanks, Robert. I'm glad I was able to break down the Work Breakdown Structure for you. Actually, my own background is in IT, both software and hardware. I use hardware examples in writing because people can picture them. It's really hard to picture an object-oriented module, now isn't it!

SidKemp profile image

SidKemp 4 years ago from Boca Raton, Florida (near Miami and Palm Beach) Author

Thanks, Leah. Cooking is a great way to teach about process and product. My best-seller on project management (Entrepreneuer Magazine's Ultimate Guide to Project Management) uses cooking examples all the way through. I was once lucky enough to sit on an airplane next to a professional chef who had read my book - and he told me that what I wrote was right on. That cheered me up.

KrisL profile image

KrisL 4 years ago from S. Florida

Like the two first commenters, I really like the examples: They make the differences crystal clear.

I also like your straightforward and unaffected writing style . . . you are good at writing just enough and not too much to explain things.

SidKemp profile image

SidKemp 4 years ago from Boca Raton, Florida (near Miami and Palm Beach) Author

Hi KrisL - I'm glad to be able to explain important things from technical sources in ways that work for everyone. I taught tech and management to adults for over 10 years - my writing comes from my speaking, and my speaking comes from my talkative family!

Sabrina 2 years ago

thank you for your explanation! but in case of a wedding, how are we supposed to do the WBS? I just can't do the difference between them...

SidKemp profile image

SidKemp 20 months ago from Boca Raton, Florida (near Miami and Palm Beach) Author

Hi Sabrina:

The WBS would contain elements, such as "cake" and "venue." The activity list would contain the actions necessary to have that element ready for the wedding. So "cake" in the WBS might be "1. choose baker; 2. choose type of cake; 3. order cake; 4. pay for and pick up cake; 5. bring cake to venue." Or, if you're baking your own cake, the activity list would be "1. choose type of cake; 2. get recipe; 3. buy ingredients; 4. bake cake; 5. bring cake to venue." So one WBS element can be achieve by two different ways of getting there, two different activity lists.

    Sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account.

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked. Comments are not for promoting your articles or other sites.

    Click to Rate This Article