Skip to main content

10 Items You Should Never Buy at a Garage Sale

What You Shouldn't Buy at a Yard Sale

Visiting a garage sale, or a yard sale, can be lots of fun. You just never know what incredible bargains you will find. Garage sales can be home to a treasure trove of antiques, collectables and the perfect items to buy cheap and resell online on websites like eBay.

Whilst it is fun handing over a small dollar or two and walking away with bundles of bits and pieces, there are at least 10 items that you should never ever buy from a garage sale.

Don't let this dissuade you at all. Just visit with an open, educated mind, and you will never walk away regretting your decisions; just don't count the impulse buys.

Items to avoid buying at a yard sale

Items to avoid buying at a yard sale

1. Electricals

You always see toasters, mixers, hair dryers, and electronics of all shapes and sizes in a garage sale. These days, most of these items are quite economical to upgrade regularly, so people are frequently 'out with the old and in with the new'. But this does not mean it is your cue to buy.

Whilst these are signals for you to buy at rock-bottom prices, it is possible they do not work or are out of warranty.

It is unlikely that you will be allowed to plug in a toaster to check it is in sound order, and don't take the lovely garage sale host's word for it. Even if they are friendly, it is not worth it. Faulty wiring may mean you could be in danger without knowing it.

Unless you are a handyman, and can competently pull apart your newfound bargain, to use for spare parts or fix what does not work, do not buy electricals.

2. Intimate Clothing

Clothing, of the personal kind, is a no-no. You should never buy undergarments, socks, swimwear, shoes or hats. Why?

  • Undergarments and socks clearly speak for themselves. And yes, people do put anything and everything out to sell.
  • Swimwear. This commonly makes an appearance, generally in the range of children's swimwear or boys' shorts. Despite the obvious hygiene concerns, they are often old and potentially thinning so may not last another wash cycle.
  • Shoes. Despite the hygiene factors which are prevalent, second-hand shoes are home to many forms of bacteria. Boots, thongs (flip-flops), lace-ups. Any kind. Are out. It really is not wise.
  • Hats are also an item to avoid. Any item worn on the head can, and most likely does, carry germs. One would not generally wash a hat, and hats are rarely cleaned before they are sold, therefore, they may contain remnants of hair products, skin cells, sweat, or skin infections. Steer well away from hats—unless you are a hat collector and plan never to wear the hat.

3. Baby Cots and Bedding

Baby cots (or cribs), mattresses and bedding are designed and manufactured under strict conditions. Child safety is paramount in this industry. These stringent standards are regularly reviewed and updated, and as a result, old designs may be deemed unsafe for your baby.

A cot may look adorable and perfect for your newborn, but there could be features in its design that could cause harm. It may have been recalled. There may be an issue with the paint it is covered with. Maybe the owners have had it re-painted or lacquered in a toxic material, unbeknownst to them.

Unless it is a brand name product with a model number visible with manufacturer's dates (and you have done your research prior), it is not worth the money you are saving for the potential risks to be caused.

Despite the safety aspects, pre-loved mattresses and bedding is most likely riddled with almost anything. Babies are messy creatures, even at the best of times. It is unhygienic.

Second-hand mattresses also pose a danger. Old mattresses can be full of dust mites, and dust mite droppings contain allergens which can be a trigger for asthma or eczema.

4. Mattresses and Bedding

Some find it hard to bypass a bargain when they see it. You might be standing in front of a double bed mattress.

It looks brilliant. It looks clean.

Just what you have been looking for. And best of all, it's FREE. You are thinking, 'Woo hoo, this is MINE'.

You must resist temptation.

Never ever buy a second-hand mattress. Even if you are told it has only been used once (yeah, right), once is too many times.

Mattresses are breeding grounds for dust mites, dead skin cells and who knows what else. No matter how cheap it is, even if it is free, do not buy it.

The same goes for any other bedding, including pillows, quilts and blankets.

Anything that has had the opportunity to be in touch with skin has grounds for being contaminated. Unless you plan to be extra creative and cut up quilts for other crafty activities (after they have been steam cleaned, dry cleaned and purified), stay away.

5. Helmets

Any helmet, whether it be a bicycle helmet or a motorcycle helmet is bad news. Just like the hat, it will most likely be home to many germs, hair mites and the like.

Furthermore, helmets undergo strict safety tests, and these tests are usually upgraded very regularly, so it is possible that you are buying an old helmet that is out of date with current regulations.

If the helmet has been in an accident, which may not be obvious to the naked eye, it may have hair-line cracks or damage, meaning it is unsafe for you.

It’s better to buy a new helmet from a bike shop, and they will make sure it fits you perfectly.

Stay away from helmets.

6. Many Children's Toys

Check children’s toys for safety hazards prior to purchasing.

Children's toys and baby equipment are designed to not have loose parts, pointy or sharp edges or other obvious safety concerns.

In their brand new form, these issues may not be present; however, after being thrown from one end of the home to the other, chewed and or broken and mended, some toys may be unsafe.

Be very wary of such possibilities. Be forewarned.

7. Personal Beauty Items

You'd be surprised at the number of personal beauty items people sell at a garage sale.

Shaving kits, eyelash curlers, hair pins, hair bands, ribbons.

All are full of germs. Full stop.

Unless they are brand new with original tags, original packaging, do not even bother. The price of these items is negligible compared to the potential germs you are inflicting on yourself.

8. Food

This is probably the item you would least expect to find at a garage sale. But believe me, you will find it at the odd one.

Even though an innocent lemonade stand, cake stall or bag of lollies looks enticing, do not eat them. Sometimes, you will see bottled jams or preserves, fruit cake or tins of biscuits. Do not buy them.

For starters, you are not familiar with the surroundings in which they were made, and with food hygiene so important, it is not worth the risk to you or your child.

Items may not be as they seem.

There could be a particular ingredient in a biscuit or a cake that you or your child are allergic too. Just because the garage sale host says no flour does not mean that there is no flour. Mistakes happen. Even innocent mistakes.

Lastly, what about used-by dates or expiry dates. You are not aware of the age of the food you are buying or eating.

Do not buy or eat food at a garage sale.

9. Pots and Pans

Pots and pans are plentiful at garage sales. Usually, they are rusty, have been well loved, a bit greasy here and there and in almost all cases, have not been washed prior to being placed on the trestle table with its $2 price tag.

Do not be tempted.

Why do you want a cheap pan when you can pass by a $2 shop or a thrift shop and get one brand new for the same price? Fine, the brand name may not be there, but the cleanliness factor is.

Ask yourself, why is the person selling it? Is it a brand-name frying pan? What is wrong with it? Even if nothing is wrong, even if they just 'upgraded' and no longer need it, you are buying germs, germs germs.

10. Car Seats for Baby and Toddler

As with baby cots and furniture, car seats are manufactured under strict guidelines, safety criteria and standards. Reviewed all too regularly, buying a second-hand car seat is a risky purchase.

The car seat may have been involved in an accident. Whilst it may look like it is in one piece, the structure of it may be flawed, or the belt frayed, and it may not ultimately protect your child in the unlikely event of another accident.

Don’t risk your child’s life.

I won't apologise for the fact that the majority of what was discussed here was germs, mites, and unhygienic habits. The truth is everyone is safe in their own world of germs. Germs are important for our immune system. We need them to help our own immune system develop. But there is a limit, and buying a second-hand item just because it is FREE or $1 is not worth the potential safety or health issues that come with it.

Remember, if you buy these 10 second-hand items at a garage sale, you are walking away with more than you can see.

Here Are Some Items You SHOULD Buy at Garage Sales

Here, on the other hand, are some categories of things you should buy at yard sales, items that can be a good investment and provide a lot of income when you resell them.

This content is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional.

© 2012 WorkAtHomeMums


Amy on May 19, 2020:

It’s funny to me how the author got so much flack in these comments over the years for being such a “germaphobe.” In May 2020 everything you’re saying sounds like the sort of thinking we maybe all should have had back when you wrote this! Especially when you write about how we are all perfectly safe in our own germ bubbles, but exposing ourselves to others’ germs for unnecessary reasons it’s a terrible mistake to make. You knew what you were talking about, and I think you’ve been proven correct!

Georgie on June 21, 2019:

Disagree on your list..Matteress I do not buy used. Appliances/Electronics any garage sale I've been to.. has always let me try them out...a person has only to ask. If not then don't buy. Most people are honest when they say it works usually it does at least in the area I live.

Undies I don't buy at yard sales but that's my personal decision.

Food items... honestly I've been buying from kids at yard sales all my life (I'm a senior)and I've never gotten sick.

Hot water n soap/ sometimes a little Elbow workout works well on sanitizing n cleaning an item.

No disrespect but .......Really this article was ridiculous.

Not everyone has the monies to buy new things no matter the item n most of us are on a budget.

Jamie on May 06, 2018:

I found myself having a great disagree on several items that you have posted that you should never buy at a yard sale. Helmets such as bicycle helmets can be washed will the bleach that will kill germs in fact that is a number item asked for. And if you look at other pages what to sale Everything basically listed not to sale is on there to sale just a little food for thought.

Ladybugs777 on September 19, 2017:

I am going to have to disagree with #6(it will be obvious when they're in poor condition), 8, and 9. I would add clothing since you don't know how it fits or looks on you it there is no mirror, and I doubt the host will let you in the house to try it on.

Chidinma Ipere on July 03, 2017:

Interesting article.

PJ on December 02, 2016:

Sorry, I just cannot agree regarding the pots & pans! A run through the dishwasher should be all that's needed to degrease & sanitize them! Scour by hand first if you feel the need. I periodically "boil out" the pots and pans that I've owned "forever" just to clean them, especially my aluminum ones, with a bit of cream of tartar to brighten the CAN'T get anything cleaner than by boiling it! If that gets me a quality pan that I couldn't otherwise afford, I'm doing it!

Rochelle Williams from Knoxville on October 20, 2016:

I don't really agree that lemonade stand food is dangerous. I've been buying brownies from kids for at least the last 15 years, and I've never had a problem. It could certainly happen that I could get some kind of bacteria or viral exposure from a kid's lemonade stand, but it doesn't appear to be a likely proposition. Mostly it just teaches kids a little about money.

We've bought a few appliances at garage sales, and they frequently don't work.

I agree about the mattresses, helmets, and car seats. Much better to buy any safety equipment new so you can research it fully. Also be on the lookout for recalled baby equipment.

Earl on July 18, 2016:

What's wrong with buying pots and pans at a garage sale? Use common sense and if they look good, and are in good condition, just wash them thoroughly before use. How about a mattress? I just helped my brother in law with a garage sale, and he sold a used mattress, which was in excellent condition, not a lot of use, for $250, retailed @ $1000.00. Even if you buy a brand new mattress, over time, it get dust mites, germs etc on it. Germs are everywhere, there's no escaping them. If no one had immunity to them, we'd all be dead. Not that what is in this article useless, but I plan on trying to sell my hardly used blender at the next garage sale I hold.

Rachael Lefler from Illinois on March 18, 2015:

Well, you can always sanitize old clothing or mattresses. I wouldn't buy underwear or swimwear at a yard sale, but hats and bike helmets can easily be sanitized with spray disinfectant or disinfecting wipes. Same goes for cribs.

Teri Stohlberg on February 02, 2015:

Great advice, thanks for posting it!

Jeocerie on December 24, 2014:

I really love the way you exerspsed your thoughts here. Mainly because they mirror many of my own. Different season, for different reasons, but it definitely resonates with me. There were periods that we were in survival mode after having three sweet babies close together, and through some periods of unemployment, and when things got back to normal I found I was still living in survival mode even though I did not have to! So for the past couple of years (work in progress!), I have been trying to become more intentional and purposeful in my life, directing more things in my days instead of letting the days fall as they may and rolling with the punches as they came. I don't know if that makes any sense, but thanks for the encouragement!

Victoria Lynn from Arkansas, USA on December 23, 2014:

I've bought some nice pots, pans, casserole dishes. There are things to stay away from, for sure, though, many of which you mention. I love yard/garage sales. Great hub!

Levertis Steele from Southern Clime on July 30, 2013:

Furniture is often bought and returned to stores within days; so are appliances, shoes, clothing, and jewelry. They are often re-sold as new. Eating out does not guarantee germ-free food. The help at cleaners may not do a thorough job of cleaning because germs are not visible to the naked eye. People sit and recline on furniture in stores. Sick people go to hotels, hospitals and use the beds, other furniture, and towels. How many people have slept in those beds? Did the housekeepers sanitize the restrooms well? We cannot get rid of these places.

Many poor and homeless people forage in trash bins for food scraps. The garage sale is a big step above the trash. Some people must buy used furniture and appliances in order to have their needs met. Some people cannot afford used things. Hopefully, they know how to clean them properly.

I know a cabinetmaker who spied a valuable piece of furniture on a trash pile, restored it and sold it to a millionaire for $2,000.00. It was mahogany, antique, and worth more. Someone said, “One man’s junk is another man’s treasure.”

While your points are sound, there are many ways that we pick up germs and skin cell and are not mindful of it. We breathe germs in the air. It is almost unavoidable, but good practices can help much as you have noted.

Annie Fenn from Australia on June 21, 2012:

Wow, well this has been an education. I go to a few garage sales, and yes you are right there lots of electrials, pots and pans, bedding, bike helmets and baby items!!! I will steer clear of these items for all the reasons you have mentioned. I do love looking for old crockery and often buy old caneware if it is good nick. I also look for old picture frames. Thanks for the advice, my votes to you WAHM.

Matthew Foreman from Las Vegas on May 31, 2012:

Great hub, come of these are common sense, helmets, undergarment, but others are things I wouldn't think of. Good to know now that Garage sale season is here.

rafeeqq from Mandeville, Jamaica on May 30, 2012:

This is really an interest hub. Good tips.

Danielle McGaw from Saskatchewan, Canada on May 30, 2012:

Great hub! I'd never thought of those things!

WorkAtHomeMums (author) from Australia on April 19, 2012:

Thank you leni for your thoughts. I have worked as an eBay trading assistant for years so I have seen a huge range of products that people try to sell and I know what sells and what doesn't and it is clear why. Thank you for your feedback.

Leni Sands from UK on April 19, 2012:

This is a really useful hub and has so many common sense facts. I work for a charity and most of what you suggest here we don't sell either for the exact reasons you suggest.

Useful and interesting hub.

HealthyBodynMind on April 16, 2012:

I had a garage sale, unfortunately I have nowhere to park my car now :-)

Seriously though, great hub.

freecampingaussie from Southern Spain on April 16, 2012:

It is a wonder I am still alive ! My best ever electric frypan was from as garage sale $5 better than an expensive new one - Never had any problems with our second hand cot , mattress , food we buy at stalls- bottled jams , cakes etc ! Interesting thoughts & I agree with some of it .

WorkAtHomeMums (author) from Australia on April 14, 2012:

Glad it has been of benefit. Many thanks. Safe shopping :)

Mark Shulkosky from Pennsylvania on April 14, 2012:

Great hub with great recommendations. These are exactly the items that show up at a garage sale and now I know not to buy. I'll stick to something safe like the velvet art.

Voted up and useful.