Christy is an eco-conscious consumer who likes to buy and acquire items used when possible.
What Is Listia?
"Listia is like Ebay, except everything is free," proclaims the LA Times quote on the Listia.com homepage. That sounds pretty great, but what exactly is Listia?
Listia is indeed very similar to eBay in many ways. It's an online auction service where users give away items they no longer want or need for "free." Other members then bid on those items using a virtual currency known as "Listia Credits" that is unique to the site.
On Listia, you can "sell" all sorts of items for Listia Credits which you can then use to bid on auctions hosted by other users for items you want. Listia Credits are not redeemable for cash and can not be used anywhere other than on the website.
My Experience and Review
I found out about Listia after seeing one of their ads online. I had a box of stuff I no longer wanted but had been too lazy to donate in my garage, so I decided to give it a try. Exchanging those things for stuff I actually want sounded like a great idea, so I created an account. I've been using the site for about a month now, and I've discovered some handy tricks and a few pitfalls as well.
Is Listia Really Free?
The short answer is that it can be. But if you don't pay close attention and use the site very carefully, it can also end up being very expensive.
Joining the site is free, and just by signing up, taking the tutorial, listing your first few auctions, and verifying your Facebook and Twitter accounts, etc., you can earn about 5,000 Listia Credits to get started.
Here's where things start to get a little dicey.
The 5 Hidden Costs of Listia
If it's your first time on Listia, there are definitely some unexpected costs that can come with using the site. Here are a few things you'll want to be aware of and watch out for:
- PayPal Verification Fee: When you join Listia, you'll have the option to verify your PayPal account with the site. Be aware that Listia charges a $1 verification fee. Many other Listians refuse to do business with members who don't have a verified PayPal account because they don't want to get scammed, so if you're serious about using the site, just look at this expense as a cost of doing business.
- Shipping Cost for Sellers: When you put an item up for auction on Listia, you have to choose what type of shipping you are going to offer. You will have the option of providing free shipping, flat rate shipping, and exact cost shipping. Shipping can be quite expensive. Be sure you fully understand the cost involved before choosing what type of shipping to offer.
- Shipping Costs for Bidders: When you bid on a Listia auction, you may end up committing more than just Listia Credits if you're not careful. Many Listians can and do charge money for shipping. If you aren't careful about the auctions you bid on, you could end up owing a lot of money in shipping costs for items that you thought were free.
- PayPal Fees: If you've decided to charge exact shipping for your Listia auctions, don't forget that PayPal is going to take its cut when your bidders reimburse you. If you aren't taking the PayPal transaction fees into account, you'll end up losing $0.30 or more per transaction. It may not sound like much, but it adds up!
- Listing Fees: When you create an auction on Listia, you have the option to set a minimum bid. If you do so, other members will not be able to place a bid that is below the minimum for that item. However, if you wish to set a minimum bid that is above 499 Credits, Listia charges a listing fee of 100 Credits for that auction.
Tips on Getting the Most Out of Listia for Free
In my time on Listia, I've had quite a few eye-opening learning experiences. I've developed some pretty good Rules to Listia By, but I sure wish I'd known them from the start! If you decide you want to give it a try, hopefully you can benefit from these tips:
- Verify your PayPal account. I know it costs a buck, but a lot of Listians won't do business with you unless you verify. This is the one and only expense that I recommend forking out if you really want to use the site.
- Charge exact shipping on your auctions. People will bid a lot less in Listia Credits if they have to pay for shipping on your auctions, but let's be honest: cold, hard cash is much more useful than Listia Credits, so keep it for yourself and let your buyers pay for shipping. Other Listians will ask you to offer free shipping occasionally (even when your auctions make it clear that you charge), but don't feel bad about refusing.
- Include PayPal fees in your shipping charges. PayPal will charge you a fee of $0.30 or more (depending on the amount of the transaction) for receiving money from other users, so build the cost of the fee into the shipping cost you charge your bidders. I use the PayPal Fee Calculator to figure out the total amount I should charge my bidders in order to get my full shipping cost reimbursed.
- Never ship items until you've been reimbursed. When I started out on the site, I assumed that other users would be basically honest and trustworthy like me. I shipped items as soon as I was given a shipping address and then let the bidder know how much they owed me . . . until I got ripped off! If you've already shipped the item and the bidder fails to reimburse you, you have no recourse. Listia can not force them to pay you. If that person wants the item, they will pay you for shipping first. If they fail to pay, you can always relist the item and find another Listian who does pay you back.
- Only bid on items that offer free shipping. Listia has an option that allows you to narrow down your searches and browse only auctions that offer free shipping, but here's the thing—that feature doesn't always work. Always, always, always double-check the shipping on an auction before bidding, or you may end up throwing down cash you didn't intend to.
- Don't buy Listia Credits. Listia allows users to purchase Credits to use on the site, but don't do it! You may see something you really want in the heat of the moment or get caught up in a competitive auction in which you only need 30 more Credits to win, but don't turn your cash into Credits—cash is much more versatile, and the point of using Listia in the first place is to save more of it.
- Sell your expensive and valuable items on eBay instead. As I've mentioned several times, Listia Credits are nice, but cash is better. If you're selling something expensive and in high demand, put it on eBay and get that green! I only put items on Listia that I think are worth less than $10 and that are probably not worth my while to sell.
- Set a minimum bid on your auctions. If you're charging shipping, many of your auctions will only get one or two people bidding on them. If you don't set a minimum bid, you may end up giving away items for a return of only 1 or 2 Credits (worth less than one penny each). Don't set your minimum bids too high or nobody will bid, but choose an amount under which it's not worth your time to ship the item. I always set mine at a minimum bid of at least 10 Credits (or more, depending on how nice the item I'm giving away is).
- Photograph the packaging for breakable items. Some members may try to claim that breakable items have broken in transit due to improper packaging on your part. I hope this won't happen to you, but it happened once to me. Another member won my auction, then claimed I didn't put any padding in the box whatsoever, and that the item arrived broken. If you take photos to show that breakable items are carefully padded before shipping, you'll have a much easier time proving your case to Listia support.
Is It a Scam?
Listia may sound pretty shady at this point, but honestly, it's not a scam. If you take the time to get to know how the site works and make sure you follow all the rules, it's possible to have a good experience and actually trade your unwanted stuff for new stuff for free. But there is a bit of a learning curve, so make sure you stay alert and exercise common sense (with a healthy dose of caution).
Although Listia itself is not a scam, some of its users are scammers (just like on eBay). But if you follow my tips, you should be able to minimize problems with other users and avoid unexpected hidden costs.
I'd also like to mention that although I've had bad experiences with a couple of other Listians, my experiences with Listia customer service have all been very positive. They can't always help, but they are responsive and genuinely willing to look into disputes and solve them as fairly as possible.
Is Listia Worth It?
Listia may not be a scam, but is it actually worthwhile? That's a tough question to answer. Posting and bidding on auctions and shipping out items is a time commitment with a very small return that consists of only a few free things every now and then.
If you have a lot of free time and not much access to money or paying jobs (and you have some stuff you'd like to give away), trying Listia probably makes sense for you.
On the other hand, if you're crazy busy and have a well-paying job to boot, Listia is probably not worth the effort in terms of taking photos, writing item descriptions, packaging items, and visiting the post office.
Personally, I like using Listia because I aim to exist in as close to a zero-waste household as much as possible. Aside from the occasional free item I've saved up enough Credits for, I get emotional satisfaction from knowing that items I no longer want will continue to be used and enjoyed by others who want or need them.
If you decide Listia sounds like a good fit for your lifestyle, I wish you a great experience, and I look forward to seeing you there.
What was your Listia experience like? Tell me about it in the comments:
Allen on April 15, 2017:
Inflation on Listia has been out of control the past couple years, they've made a lot of changes that I hope keeps it under control. I still use Listia for exchanging digital items and occasionally getting rid of promotional items I get that I dont have a use for.
I also use it for the reduction in waste, the idea of sharing what we have instead of buying stuff brand new, reducing the impact on the environment. Shipping something from here to there has less of an impact than manufacturing a brand new version.
I miss sites like Yerdle which I thought did this whole process better. Theres other smaller sites starting to pop up I'm keeping an eye on such as SwapCaps for more ways to share. I hope these sites keep going.
Jarmila Eliasova on March 30, 2017:
Yes, Listia is good, only if you try to give free stuff, and you willing to pay money out of your pocket. I was selling on Listia for 5 years. Because I was a big seller and with 100% feedback, then I get opportunity about 1.5 ago, to sell my credits. But after credits was getting ridiculously cheep, Listia put stop and you could sell them for one price. Problem is waiting time. I sell was selling weekly, and paying shipping for 30-40 shipments every week. So I'm in $300 and more in red, because Listia is selling Amazon gift cards, with digital delivery (so no cost to Listia) and they give them selves priority in selling credits. So because they sell a few million credits every single day on Amazon cards, people are paying actually $30-40 for card with value of $15. SO Listia is making so many credits, then other sellers are no longer served with selling credits. I have still for sale over million credits from February 8 till 17. For 10 days no one of my credits, that I put up for sale was sold. I guess, because I make a few complains to listia, they hold my money and also my credits will not sell anymore. So this I have to see as fraud. I give them so much business, and I will turn to every opportunity to tell everyone, how you will get screwed by Listia stuff. I would like to withdraw my money, but I can't because I have to sell credits for $20+ but my money are sitting in my account, and my over million credits are no longer selling, due to Lista's actions !!! I will turn to every opportunity to give my experience with listia to public !!!
Christy Kirwan (author) from San Francisco on February 21, 2017:
You can also block users who have been shady or haven't followed through so that you never have to worry about bidding on their auctions again accidentally.
ihubber45 on February 17, 2017:
Having been a user for about 18 months, I find somethings either have to just be taken with a grain of salt and note which players are fair or not. I have not received items stated to have been shipped to me and will remember with whom to do business and choose not to bid on those who don't send as indicated. Buyers have been happy with what they have won from me and some of them got a lot for a low bid- it's all in making others happy with what isn't useful to me anymore- that's fun to see. I have chosen to set a base bid on my auction item.
Rebecca- as for your bids where another immediately out-bids you: they are using software that checks new bids and automatically ups the ante, so-to-speak. So the choice is for you to investigate using that software also or see if you can be the last-second bidder; it's a risk and part of the game, it seems. There is a description of using that software in Listia Help tool.
albgenius on September 19, 2016:
I have never heard about Listia before. Your article not only presented it very well but cautioned us about the mistakes we can make using it. I might give it a try in the future.
Andrea on August 23, 2016:
Great run down and review. I've used Listia for almost a year. I love it but agree it has its pitfalls. I almost always charge free shipping, however, you made quite a compelling argument that I'm now taking into consideration. I will say that one can offer free shipping on Listia and still manage to turn a profit by being strategic in your own auctions so as to get the most credits for your items, which in turn gives you buying power on Listia. I then search for specific auctions where I can and do win nice items for a very reasonable and sometimes just downright low amount of credits. Then I turn around and sell those items on eBay. But there is one thing for sure, no matter how you play it, you absolutely have to be mindful and strategic on Listia in order to make it work for you. Lastly, I want to mention that Listia can be valuable in other ways. There are the bad apples out there, but overall, a great and tight knit community exists on Listia. Also if you have any specific hobbies, chances are, Listia has a community of people with the same interests. I'm what is known as a "rock hounder" and I love collecting rocks and gemstones. I've learned so much and met so many other young female Rock hounders on Listia, and that is really valuable to me.
Mel Carriere from Snowbound and down in Northern Colorado on September 29, 2015:
I am always learning about new services here on Hub Pages. It sounds worth a shot, but the shipping could be a deal killer for me. Great hub!
Christy Kirwan (author) from San Francisco on June 29, 2015:
Some people will probably feel morally obligated to offer free shipping, but I don't think fairness really comes into the equation at all. People can choose to bid only on auctions that offer free shipping, but most of my auctions (that charge for shipping) also get bids, which indicates that many Listia users don't mind paying shipping if they're getting something nice enough. I also think Listia is essentially a capitalist micro-economy where self-interested behavior is not inherently bad for the community so long as it falls within the rules.
GroovyGirl from Massachusetts, USA on June 27, 2015:
I have been a member of Listia for many years and get much enjoyment out of the site! I offer free shipping on all my auctions and only bid on auctions that offer free shipping in return. That is how Listia was meant to be. In your article you encourage people to charge shipping but only bid on auctions that are free. That's not exactly fair. Free goes both ways.
Audrey Selig from Oklahoma City, Oklahoma on April 27, 2015:
It sounds complicated, but you have explained it well. I have only bought one item from Ebay, so am not very familiar with these types of sites. It sounds exciting to get rid of stuff, but I guess we like using the donation pick up Agencies. I have never heard of Listia, so really enjoy learning about new experiences. Blessings, Audrey
PaigSr from State of Confusion on March 16, 2015:
Thanks for the break down. I had heard a little bit in the past about Listia. At this time I don't think that they are for me. Over all you break down and advice has been greatly appreciated.
Rebecca on January 06, 2015:
I can never get anything on there because everything always goes to several thousand points fast. Just in a couple of hours something I was watching went from a couple hundred to a couple thousand. Can't seem to get anything because this always happens. I don't have enough things I could post that would get me points so I'd end up having to buy points if I wanted items and then that defeats the whole getting it for free from Listia thing which is why I would use Listia in the first place.
Techno Novice on July 14, 2014:
So helpful!! I hate reading through the fine print, and your tips reduced all that to something much more digestible. Great information to have before taking the Listia plunge!
Christy Kirwan (author) from San Francisco on June 19, 2014:
Thanks, grand old lady! I ended up spending about $4 myself while getting to know the ins and outs of the site and finding the pitfalls, so hopefully my experience can save other newbies some money. :)
Mona Sabalones Gonzalez from Philippines on June 06, 2014:
Never heard about Listia till now. I appreciate that you have shared not only your experience, but the loopholes and have given advice on how to use it without having to go through those nasty loopholes. Good hub.
Alastar Packer from North Carolina on May 30, 2014:
Thanks, Christy. Your oh so right but the very thought of letting one-red cent of taxable income slip through their legislator hands drives them to unsentimental rage.
Christy Kirwan (author) from San Francisco on May 30, 2014:
Thanks for reading, Alastar. That's really too bad that NC doesn't allow it. Hopefully they'll change their legislation at some point to allow residents more freedom to participate in online commerce. The sad thing is that the people those restrictions hurt most are usually lower income people just trying to make a little extra to get by.
Alastar Packer from North Carolina on May 29, 2014:
Very good read-thorough and much important info; thanks , Christy. One can only wish the state of N.C. and a couple of others would allow their residents to participate in , Amazon, Ebay,...and, Listia, if they so choose.