Trading Options on Futures Contracts: Tips With Selling Short - ToughNickel - Money
Updated date:

Trading Options on Futures Contracts: Tips With Selling Short

Author:

Glenn Stok writes about investment and risk-control strategies that he has perfected during 45 years trading stocks, options, and futures.

There will always be someone on the other side of the trade when you sell short.

There will always be someone on the other side of the trade when you sell short.

This article will be most helpful if you already know what put and call options are, and that you understand the difference between trading long and short. So I'll give a quick review before getting into it.

When you sell options short on stocks or futures, the odds are in your favor. That’s because options lose value as they reach expiration due to time decay.

When you sell short1, you can buy options back at a lower price and keep the difference as a profit or let them expire and keep 100% of the funds received, less the commission.

Most traders only think of buying options (going long). Those traders lose most of the time. The person buying options needs to be right with his or her assumption of the direction the underlying instrument will take.

When you sell short, time decay is your friend. Even if you’re wrong, you can still profit if the stock or future doesn’t move too far in the wrong direction.

Now that we got through that preliminary stuff, I’ll give you some tips for successfully trading options on futures.2

Sell Premium on Futures When Volatility Is High

Selling options is known as selling premium, but you want that premium to be as high as possible, so you increase the chances of it eroding in value quickly. Remember that term: Time Decay.

To know that you are getting a decent premium, watch the volatility. It’s the best indicator. Every commodity has a different volatility index.

For example, I sell premium on the E-mini S&P Futures options. I keep an eye on the VIX. That’s the implied volatility of the S&P 500 index options.

The Chicago Board Options Exchange (CBOE) calculates the VIX on a continuous bases while the futures are trading.

When the VIX is historically low, I wouldn’t think of selling short. However, when I see an opportunity because the S&P suddenly shot up or down, I check the VIX. If it also moved up, I might consider selling a put or a call option, depending on which way the market moved.

When you expect the market (or commodity) to go up, sell a put. That means you’re long the market. A put option will lose value when the market goes up. It will also lose value if the market doesn’t move at all. That's due to the incredible time decay again.

Reversely, if you expect the market to drop, sell a call. That means you’re short the market. A call option will lose value when the market goes down or stays the same.

Define Your Risk to Limit Losses

When you buy a stock, you risk all the money you invested. With options, you have more control over your risk, as long as you include the following method with all your trades. (This works for stock options as well as options on futures).

I'll explain it with an insurance analogy. You sell short, and you buy insurance to lock yourself into a max loss. The insurance is actually an out-of-the-money option that you buy real cheap.

Here’s a simple example to show how this works:

In the last section, I spoke about selling either a put or a call. Remember, when you sell short, you collect the premium for that sale. That is also known as selling naked.You’re not protected if things go wrong, as I’ll explain.

If it loses value, which is what you want, you can buy it back at the lower price and keep the difference as your profit. In some cases, you may just let it expire worthless, and you keep everything (less commission from the initial sale).

However, if the underlying future commodity does not go the way you thought it would, the option can grow in value. If that happens, you can lose on that trade because you would have to buy it back at a higher price.

The difference is a loss in that case. Time decay may help a little, but only if it doesn’t move to extremes. If things really get bad, that option can grow tremendously, and you can lose a lot.

However, here’s where defining your risk becomes beneficial. If you buy another option way out of the money at the same time when you sell short, you lock yourself into a fixed max loss.

A Quick Example

Here’s a quick example without getting into any particulars, and ignoring commissions:

Say the S&P is trading at 3100, and you think it won’t go below 3000 in the next 30 days.

You sell a put option to expire in 30 days at a strike of 3000 and receive a premium of $8. Each E-mini S&P option is for 1 S&P contract, and each contract has a $50 multiplier, so you receive $400. (The multiplier defines the actual value of each futures contract, known as the notional value).

At the same time, you buy a put option at a strike of 2900, and you pay $2.90 (option price) multiplied by the $50 S&P multiplier, which is $145.

Therefore, you receive $400 less $145, or $255 for the trade. Sure, you get less than the full $400, but that long option locks you into a defined risk of $5,000.

How did I arrive at that risk figure? You sold an option at a strike of 3000 and bought one at a strike of 2900. That’s a 100-point difference, also known as the spread. Multiply that by $50 (the S&P multiplier). 100 x 50 = $5,000.

Actually, your true risk is even lower. It’s $4,745. That’s because you received $255 for the trade ($5,000 – $255 = $4,745).

A 100 spread trade selling one E-mini S&P Option Contract

 Strike PricePremium

Sell E-mini S&P PUT

3000

$400

Buy E-mini S&P PUT

2900

$145

Amount Received

 

$255

If you didn’t buy that long option and the market kept going the wrong way, you could lose endlessly, up to infinity. Of course, your broker would give you a margin call and pull you out before that happens, but at a tremendous loss, nevertheless.

When you define your risk, you’ll never get a margin call. No matter how bad things get, you can’t lose more than the amount you defined as your risk, or $5,000 in this example.

You can make that risk larger or smaller, depending on your risk tolerance, simply by making the spread larger or smaller.

In case you’re wondering what the percentage gain is, if the option expires worthless, divide the amount you received ($255) by the risk ($5,000). That’s a 5% profit in 30 days. Keep repeating that, and you’re making 60% per year on a $5,000 investment. However, I don’t recommend being greedy.

Don't be greedy. Take profits when you have them.

Don't be greedy. Take profits when you have them.

Take Profits Early

Greed is our enemy. Many people hope to keep all the money by waiting and letting the trade expire worthless because options tend to lose value over time, due to time decay.

They think they are saving the commission since they don’t have to buy it back. However, this strategy is impractical for two reasons:

  1. Markets and commodities can turn around any time and move quickly in the wrong direction. Therefore it works best to take profits when you have a 50% gain on the options trade. There is no need to wait for expiration. A gain can be lost if the market turns on you.

    Of course, you can always roll down. But rolling takes extra resources, and you might just be priced out of the market if you need to keep rolling month after month.

    That’s why you should close the trade when you have a 50% gain.

  2. The second reason why waiting for expiration is impractical is that you are tying up your money for the entire time of the trade. If you already have a 50% profit within a month, take it.

    That will also free up your resources so you can enter a new trade when the opportunity presents itself. You might find yourself repeating several trades in a month to make much more without using extra resources. Isn’t that better than waiting for that single trade to expire?

There you have it. Remember to use your due diligence when you enter a trade. Never be greedy and take your profits early. That’s the best strategy.

Trading Options on Futures Gives You Leverage

Futures only require a small amount of margin to hold the contract. That gives you leverage. However, leverage can work against you fast when the price of the contract goes against you. That’s why selling options helps, since the options decay as time goes on.

Nevertheless, you need to keep a close eye on things. If you let it go too far in the wrong direction, you would have to repurchase the options at a higher price or take delivery on the futures commodity. You wouldn’t want to do either of those.

For that reason, it's worthwhile taking profits early when you have it. The general rule of taking profits on decaying options is to close the trade when you have a 50% gain. If you hope for a home run, things can turn against you if the market changes.

On the other hand, if things go badly right from the start, get out as soon as the trade reaches the maximum you are willing to lose. As long as you learn to get out quickly when you’re wrong, this type of activity can be quite fruitful.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Futures Contracts

It's important to understand both extremes of any endeavor. So I'll complete this discussion with a list of the pros and cons of trading options on futures.

Advantages:

  • Gains on futures have a tax advantage. IRS Section 1256 allows you to report 60% of the profits as Long Term. That is so no matter how briefly you hold the trade. It’s similar for futures as well as the options on futures. With stocks, you need to hold the shares over a year for that tax advantage.
  • You can buy or sell futures contracts as easily as trading stocks.
  • You have leverage. The margin is nowhere near the actual value of the commodity. That’s called the Notional Value, which is beyond the scope of this article, but in a few words: It’s the market value times the leverage.
  • There are no day-trading limits with futures. The IRS will consider you a day trader if you trade stocks more than three times each day. That does not apply to futures contracts, so you can take quick profits with small intraday swings and get right back in again. Doing this with stocks can sometimes cause “Wash Sale Penalties.” But not with futures.
  • Futures trade nearly 24 hours a day. They only pause on weekends and a few minutes at the end of each day for exchange record keeping.
  • Most options on futures are European Style and can't be exercised before expiration. So you won’t have your trade closed prematurely because the buyer wants to exercise their option. There are some exceptions—American Style can be exercised anytime, as is the case with most stock options.

Disadvantages:

  • Futures trade like stocks, but you own part of the company when you buy shares of stock. The difference is that futures are contracts for a future sale or purchase. You are obligated to buy or sell the commodity that the contract relates to at a later date at a specific price.
  • You tie up margin while holding futures contracts no matter if you buy long or sell short.
  • Remember that you are dealing with a contract. If the trade goes against you and you don’t buy back the option to close the trade, you may have to pay the full price of the underlying commodity upon expiration.
  • Pricing on futures is recorded as Marked to Market. That means you have to pay tax on the gains even if you hold a contract into the next year.

References

  1. Selling Short Explained (Wikipedia)
  2. Options on Futures (CME Group)

This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.

© 2016 Glenn Stok

Comments

Glenn Stok (author) from Long Island, NY on November 14, 2018:

Mike - Selling covered calls on a long position is another strategy you can use. But if the underlying stock or future goes way down, you will lose much more than the money you'd make on the premium from selling the covered call. So you need to consider that, as you alluded to in your comment.

The method I described in this article locks you in to a fixed max loss, therefore defining your risk as I explained.

Mike on October 25, 2018:

What you think of doing covered call writing ( LONG futures + Short ATM or OTM call)

If it works great return on margin money applied due to ES own internal leverage

BUT if ES goes down the losses are multiplied!

Glenn Stok (author) from Long Island, NY on October 28, 2016:

chefsref - What you just described is exactly what I was talking about. Your emotions get in the way and cause you to make mistakes. I personally don't like mutual funds because they take out fees if they succeed for fail. I can't give you advice since I'm not a licensed broker, so if that's working for you, stick to it.

Lee Raynor from Citra Florida on October 28, 2016:

Hey Glenn

One thing I never see mentioned in trading advice is emotions. I could trade on paper and be fairly successful but put money on the line and it becomes diffficult to stay disciplined and I make errors. Thus I stay away and merely buy mutual funds.

Any advice?

Good Hub

Lee