Kristen hails from Modesto, CA. She is self-employed and has experience selling with Storenvy.
My Experience Selling With Storenvy
If you're thinking of selling your homemade products online, you're probably well aware that you have several options. There are a number of websites out there that make it simple for people to set up a store and start selling, Etsy.com and Storenvy.com being two of the largest and best-known. These kinds of sites are easy for people who don't have the knowledge, funds, or time to set up their own independent websites. They simply create a merchant account and start listing products.
When I started my own handmade business in 2014, I weighed several options before choosing a site to sell with. I chose Storenvy mainly because other people I knew were using it, and the options for customization were far better than many of its competitors. Now that I've been using Storenvy for a couple of years, it's safe to say I'm pretty familiar with it.
I'm here to give you all the details about what you can expect if you set up your online store with Storenvy.
One of the things I like most about Storenvy is how easy it is to use. Setup is a breeze and takes almost no time at all. Within a few minutes of creating your account, you can list your products and start selling them!
Everything is basically in a "fill in the box" style, meaning that all you have to do is enter your store name, your bio, a photo if you'd like, choose your color scheme, etc. You don't have to worry about coding or formatting elements at all, it's all done for you. It's kind of like coloring in a coloring book. The design is already done for you, you just have to color in the blanks.
The downside of being so simple is that options for customization are very limited. Aside from picking the colors, fonts, and background images, you really don't have any freedom to change the way your site looks. You have only a handful of preset templates to choose from, and that's it.
While this was wonderful at first, it wasn't long before I got to the point where I wanted more for my site. I began to get very frustrated that I couldn't create new pages, add a blog, or design a homepage with a "welcome video" on it. Of course, you may not be interested in something like that. Just beware that you will not have very much freedom to be creative.
Cost of Doing Business
The pricing was one of the main reasons I decided to go with Storenvy! It's free to set up your store, and you can list up to 500 products at a time. There are no monthly subscription fees. There used to be no transaction fee either, but it looks like Storenvy recently added one. They are currently "testing out" the addition of a "nominal fee" to transactions. Although they don't seem to specify exactly how much this fee is, it's worth looking into.
They also charge you extra if you want the following premium features that you don't have access to otherwise:
- Custom domain – $5/month: Without this, your web address will look like this: mystore.storenvy.com. However, if you purchase your own custom domain, it can look like this: mystore.com. If you want your own custom domain, you will have to go elsewhere to purchase one, like GoDaddy or BlueHost. Prices for this vary and are separate from the $5 Storenvy charge. That's just the charge for you not using their .storenvy.com address.
- Discounts – $9/month: If you sell products, you'll probably want to offer promotions at some point. This add-on lets you create promo codes so your customers can get "X% off" or "Buy X get X free."
Another noteworthy cost is the fact that Storenvy will not handle your transactions by themselves. For that, they integrate with Stripe and PayPal, who both charge their own fees on every transaction. So not only is Storenvy taking a cut of all your sales, but Stripe and PayPal have a hand in your cash register, too. While these fees stay pretty small, they can really add up when combined, especially if you're making significant amounts of money through your Storenvy shop!
Actually selling your stuff on Storenvy is a pretty painless process. You just add your product info into their "fill in the blank" template, upload a photo, and list it for sale. You even have the ability to add variants (like different prices for different sizes) and keep track of inventory.
Once you've sold a product, Storenvy does a pretty good job of notifying you right away. I always got an email within seconds of a new sale. You can then package the product and ship it off.
Read More From Toughnickel
Please note that Storenvy does not currently calculate shipping costs for you. This is one of the biggest struggles I had with running a Storenvy shop. You have to estimate the shipping cost of the product before you even list it for sale. I did this by creating "shipping groups" in the settings. I had one for candles, one for jewelry, etc. I estimated shipping costs based on how much the products typically weigh. I dislike this because you are never accurately charging your customers for shipping.
Other than that, the selling process runs pretty smoothly on Storenvy.
Marketplace: They Help You Sell
Storenvy has this little thing they call "The Marketplace," which is like their own virtual flea market.
If you've ever shopped on Storenvy.com, you're using their Marketplace. It helps put your stuff in the face of customers who might not have found it otherwise. You can choose whether you want to participate in the Marketplace or not.
If you do, they set you up with a profile in their Marketplace. This is totally separate from your "storefront" website that you set up on your own. The plus is that they help direct the right traffic to your "Marketplace Store." The downside is that they take a 10% cut of anything you sell using their Marketplace, which is presumably more than the amount they charge you on purchases made from your own storefront.
Personally, I wasn't a fan of the Marketplace. Yes, it brings in customers who might not find you otherwise. However, I started to feel kind of cheated by the Marketplace after a while. I began to notice that when I typed my store name into a search engine, my listing in the Marketplace came up in the results before the listing for my own storefront did. This meant that many customers who were looking for my shop were being directed through Storenvy's Marketplace instead of directly to my shop. This meant that Storenvy got a cut of all those sales. I felt that this was very unfair, given that those customers were not gained through any help of the Storenvy Marketplace. No matter what I did, search engine results always took people to the Marketplace. The only way I could make a sale through my own Storefront was if I gave my customer the direct link. Because of this, I decided to opt out of Marketplace participation.
It'll be up to you to decide if this is worth it or not. You can open or close your "Marketplace Store" anytime you want, though, so you're not obligated to anything if you just want to try it out.
To me, integration with other services is a big deal. It wasn't until after I had invested a bunch of time into Storenvy that I realized their integration with other services is not so great.
There are a few "apps" that you can add to your store for extra functionality. Two notable examples are Kudobuzz (for collecting customer reviews) and ShippingEasy (for buying and printing shipping labels). However, if you're not satisfied with these apps, then you're S.O.L. If you want to look around for other options, they won't be compatible with your website.
For example, I wanted to start using MailChimp to send out monthly newsletters and special offers. Unfortunately, there was no way for me to install an opt-in form on my website.
In addition, I thought KudoBuzz was complete garbage. I found much better options for collecting customer reviews, but there was no way for me to work them into my site. I was stuck.
I reached a point where I thought it would be a good idea to use LeadPages to create a landing page where I could send a specific message to customers (aside from the very generic homepage that I got from Storenvy). Guess what? I couldn't do that either.
Of course, none of this may matter to you! I didn't even know what any of these things were when I started selling. But it wasn't long before these things made it onto my radar and I got frustrated that I couldn't play around and be creative with my sales tactics.
In my opinion, Storenvy is not very reliable. It crashed way too frequently for my liking while I was using it. The problems that frustrated me the most were:
- The website glitched and couldn't process transactions. This happened way too frequently, and as far as I could tell, it was site-wide.
- Everything worked except for the shop owner dashboard. This meant that customers could still shop and buy, but you'd have no access to your orders page to look at and process the orders that were coming in. This wouldn't be a huge deal if it weren't for the fact that it was down for almost three whole days! This seriously delayed the shipping process for the orders that came in during that time.
- There were a few times that I had to go around Storenvy and take sales from my customers through PayPal directly. It was when this started happening that I decided I needed to take my business elsewhere.
Maybe my expectations are too high, but I think that a website that makes tons of money from the people who use it to make money should at least be functional on a regular basis. When your website is down, it reflects badly on you as a business owner, whether it's your fault or not. And when it gets in the way of your ability to bring in money, it becomes a serious problem.
In their defense, I have heard tons of stories of people who are totally satisfied and have never had a problem. Unfortunately, I am not one of those people.
Compare for Yourself
When you're setting up an online store, there will be highs and lows no matter which platform you decide to use.
I highly advise comparing a few of the platforms that look most appealing to you and considering testimonials from people who have actually used them before. I stayed with Storenvy for over two years before I began to outgrow its limitations and began to look elsewhere. However, there are people who never leave Storenvy because their shop is so successful right where it is!
I am very glad that I picked Storenvy as a starting point. I think that they made the transition into being a new business owner extremely simple, and I was able to learn so much while I was running my Storenvy shop!
If you have any specific questions about selling on Storenvy that I didn't answer here, or if you have your own testimonial to add, please leave them in the comments!
This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.
© 2016 Kristen Haynie
Sue Lowery on July 27, 2020:
Good explanation, but if I were a seller, I would stay far away. As a purchaser, I would say they are great at TAKING your money for products from stores that out of business, and then it is up to buyer to report the fraud and get money refunded, no not from them, from your credit card.
Even though I have alerted Storeenvy to this, I CONTINUE to get emails from them selling MULTIPLES of a product from a defunct store. They can conveniently claim "no responsibility" while taking your credit card over and over.
sahar6892 on July 26, 2020:
I want to sell my handmade
How can do it?
Jess on June 01, 2018:
Though I love store envy for the hours I save on learning the technicalities of setting up a functioning store and their new integrations with social media,...... i must agree as well VERY well written. Even not having walked your shoes I feel like you downloaded the real experiences to me. Thanks!! Followed you on facebook.
Cecilia on March 10, 2018:
Kristen, I totally agree with the others, this article is quite helpful and written with great organization and clarity. So do you still have your shop with storenvy or have you moved onto a different platform or have your own website now? Very curious, and I would love to check out your store. Thank you!
Angela on January 27, 2018:
This says you can't have a welcome video but I have seen someone have a welcome video on their storenvy before... I am wondering how they did it.
Tyler on October 25, 2017:
Super useful article. Lots of good info to help me make some decisions, so thank you for that!
* Get ~ More * on October 03, 2017:
How much Money does a store Averages a Month
Jimmy on August 08, 2017:
I find your review refreshingly candid, helpful and balanced. Thank you for sharing your insights and experiences with using Storenvy.
Kristen Haynie (author) from Scotia, CA on June 25, 2017:
It's kind of hard with Storenvy. They do have a "marketplace" feature that allows them to promote your products for you. You have to give them a cut of your profits if you participate though and in my experience, the Storenvy Marketplace is terrible in terms of finding customers to send your way!
I recommend promoting your Storenvy store just like you would any other web site. Use social media. Google Ads have always worked well for me, even though they are kind of pricey. I highly advise against relying on Storenvy to promote your store for you. Chances are, you won't get very far if you use that and no other tactics.
Best of luck to you!
Lori on June 08, 2017:
How do you recommend I market my storeenvy store in order to be successful?