Poppy is the author of "A Bard's Lament" and the Black Diamond series. She lives in Enoshima, Japan, with her husband and young son.
With the rise of the internet and electronic books, the book publishing industry has transformed over the past twenty years. It has never been easier—or more difficult—for writers to get published.
Self-publishing is a possibility for unknown writers to get their work on Amazon and other online bookstores. There are many very successful self-published writers, such as Christopher Paolini (Eragon) and E. L. James (Fifty Shades of Grey).
However, self-publishing means that the author has to put a lot of effort and money into advertising, and most writers don't have the time, knowledge, or funds to be able to effectively promote their own work. Getting traditionally published, then, is the dream of most writers.
Like most topics, the easiest and fastest way to get a list of publishers and literary agents (who help you find a publisher) is via the internet. Unfortunately, there are people out there who know how badly writers want to get published. They use this to their advantage, and those who are initially excited to hear they're getting published sometimes end up ripped off and heartbroken.
When I was seventeen, excited and hopeful for the future, I came across an agency online that promised to become my agent. However, I found out that they were fake before it was too late. I also have met authors who have been burned; one told me she paid $300 for "professional feedback" only to get a page from someone who clearly hadn't read it.
To ensure something like this doesn't happen to you, here are some tips to spot a fake publisher or agency from a real one.
How to Spot a Fake Publisher
- They ask for money.
- They can't provide a list of authors they represent.
- Clues on their website.
- They aren't mentioned in other sources.
- They don't tell you their names.
1. They Ask for Money
This is a big one. No real publisher or agency will ever ask you for money. These fakers will nearly always ask you to pay for some "expenses" yourself, such as the following:
- The editor's fee: they'll say they're happy to publish your work, but you have to pay for editing.
- The feedback fee: some agencies will say they don't want to publish your book but ask you to send money for them to give you "detailed feedback."
- Printing costs: no real publisher will ever ask the writer to pay for printing.
The whole point of a publisher is to cover the costs of editing, proofreading, printing, shipping, and advertising. That's why they get most of the profits. If they ask for money, they're frauds.
2. They Can't Provide a List of Authors They Represent
If you've found someone willing to represent your work, they should have no problem providing a list of authors they are already working with. Most of the time, you shouldn't even have to ask, as they'd usually have a list on their website.
When I was dealing with the fake agency, I asked them to send me a list of authors who they were working with, and they stopped replying.
This is so effective because it's so easy to check it. If they give you names, you can easily find the names on the internet, check out their work, and match the name of their publisher to the name you're dealing with. Genuine companies will have no problems sending you this data.
3. Clues on Their Website
The easiest way for scammers to work is by creating a website, coming up with a genuine-sounding name for an agent or publisher, and sticking an email address in the "Contact Us" section with which they can communicate with hopeful writers. However, a fake website has a lot of clues. Check their page for these dead giveaways:
- "WRITERS WANTED." Real publishers and agents are swamped with manuscripts every single day. They rarely advertise for more.
- No list of authors. As mentioned before, a successful company should already have authors and books they're representing.
- Fake testimonials. For example, you might see a list of feedback that says something along the lines of "'Great agency, I got published right away!' - Sally." With no surname, you can't check out the writer's name. Genuine publishers don't need testimonials because, again, they're always having manuscripts sent to them and don't need to advertise.
- No book advertisements. Though this isn't as black-and-white as the others, most real publishing houses and agencies will have at least one of their books displayed as a form of advertising.
The website may also look shoddy and unprofessional, with a basic layout, possibly grammatical or spelling mistakes, and nothing on the website except details on how to submit your work and get rich rich rich.
4. They Aren't Mentioned in Other Sources
Do a quick search of the company's name on Google and see what other sites say about them. If they've scammed people before, you may find information about them on review sites. If there's no information about them at all, you know they're no good.
5. They Don't Tell You Their Names
If a company is genuinely interested in working with you, you're going to be introduced to at least one or two human names during your communications. A fake obviously doesn't want to be found out, so their emails will nearly always end with the agency name or perhaps just a first name.
A real company will have, at the end of a business email, a full name, website, and address. If you don't see these, it's another sign you might be talking to a scammer.
A way for British writers to find a real publisher is with the Writers' and Artists' Yearbook. It is updated annually and only contains genuine companies. It's very easy to use and displays the genres and types of manuscripts they are looking for. It's highly recommended if you're living in the UK and you're serious about getting published.
Scammers are constantly getting more cunning, and all they are interested in is getting their hands on your money. With these four tips, you will be able to easily spot a fake publisher or literary agency, giving you more time to send proposals to real companies.
This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.
© 2018 Poppy
ErikaPeaches on October 15, 2018:
Thank-you for your advice, Poppy. I will definitely check out the Writers and Artists Yearbook's website.
Poppy (author) from Enoshima, Japan on October 07, 2018:
Thanks for your comment! I did a little research on TouchPoint Press. It seems they are a real publisher, but they look very amateur. Their website doesn’t look professional and their book covers are very basic looking, similar to self-published works. I would suggest looking for a company with a better reputation.
Try the Writers and Artists Yearbook! It’s only got legitimate agents and publishers in it.
ErikaPeaches on October 06, 2018:
"...It sounds very much like a scammer!..."
Sorry it took so long for me to reply, my computer broke down.
The name of the publishing house is TouchPoint Press. I came across them from a directory of horror book publishers, not from a google search. No, the email did not mention anything specific about my manuscript and they have not asked for money yet, but I'm sure if I responded to them they would.
I am not going to respond to this publisher. If I'm questioning their validity from the first email they sent me, then TouchPoint Press must be scammers.
Poppy (author) from Enoshima, Japan on September 30, 2018:
It sounds very much like a scammer! What is the publishing house called? Where did you hear of it - from a reputable source or just by searching Google? Did they mention anything specific about your manuscript? Have they asked for money?
ErikaPeaches on September 29, 2018:
I sent a publishing house an query email at 4:10pm and received a request for my full manuscript at 4:40pm. There is not a name in the request for my manuscript, only "Acquisitions". The publishing house's website has a list of over 50 authors, but the speedy response with the ending salutation of "Acquisitions" is making me vary wary. What do you guys think? Could this possibly be a scammer?
Sp Greaney from Ireland on February 27, 2018:
There's always opportunists out there who will find new ways to take advantage of people. This is good advice for anyone thinking of using this method.
Poppy (author) from Enoshima, Japan on January 19, 2018:
Thank you, Lauren :)
Lauren Flauding from Sahuarita, AZ on January 19, 2018:
It's a shame that so many are trying to profit off of the dreams of aspiring writers. I published my first book through a vanity publisher, but now I just self publish. Great advice in here!
Mamerto Adan from Cabuyao on January 09, 2018:
And thanks too! This hub could really help our newbie authors.
Poppy (author) from Enoshima, Japan on January 08, 2018:
Excellent choice. No doubt they were trying to scam you. Why would they bother advertising and selling your book if the author already gave them money? Thank you for commenting, Mamerto.
Mamerto Adan from Cabuyao on January 08, 2018:
Yup, this all fits. Years ago a publisher approached me, offering me to publish my works, but I have to pay several hundreds of dollars first. After that I basically ignored their email and moved on.
Poppy (author) from Enoshima, Japan on January 08, 2018:
Thank you :) hopefully people can benefit from it.
FlourishAnyway from USA on January 08, 2018:
This is an excellent piece of advice. It’s unfortunate that people would have to be a detective to avoid fraud, but it’s necessary these days. Offering your personal experience was beneficial too.