Skip to main content

What to Do When a Buyer Claims an eBay Item Wasn't Delivered

As a top-rated eBay seller, I want to help all eBay sellers realize their potential for maximum sales and best practices.

If an eBay buyer claims they didn't receive an item you sent them, you may not owe them a refund.

If an eBay buyer claims they didn't receive an item you sent them, you may not owe them a refund.

To Experienced and New Sellers

Whether you are an eBay newbie or an experienced, high-volume seller, you are most likely going to have to deal with an "item not delivered" case at some point. These cases can be discouraging, but certain procedures must be followed regardless. There are four possible reasons you might run into an "item not received" case, but regardless of the reason, you may be protected.

Article Contents

  • Am I Protected as an eBay Seller?
  • The 4 Possible Reasons for an "Item Not Received" Case
  • How to Avoid Negative eBay Feedback if a Buyer Doesn't Receive Their Package
  • How to Address an "Item Not Received" Claim
  • What Final Decision Can I Expect?

Am I Protected as an eBay Seller?

The one absolute way to protect yourself as a seller is to use eBay or PayPal shipping labels. Using one of those two services ensures that you have done everything possible from your end to ensure the buyer's package is en route to the address the buyer provided.

So, to answer the question that most sellers may have, if you have used one of the two services mentioned above, and the tracking information shows that the item was delivered, you are protected by eBay's seller-protection program and are not required to refund the buyer.

In eBay's opinion, you did everything you could before the postal service took possession of the package. Once it has left your possession, you are no longer in control of the package's destination. Unfortunately, the buyer can still leave negative feedback on your profile if they choose.

The 4 Possible Reasons for an "Item Not Received" Case

There are four (and only four) reasons an item can be marked as delivered but not received by the buyer.

1. The Buyer Is Lying

Believe it or not, this is the most common reason for an "item not received" claim. Fortunately, this is usually the easiest scenario to address. If a buyer is lying about receiving an item, they have probably done so in the past or will do so again in the future.

If the buyer has less than five feedback ratings and/or has been an eBay member for less than a month, chances are you are dealing with a shady customer—pardon the pun.

2. The Item Has Not Been Delivered Yet

As with any profession, the postal service has employees that do not always follow the rules and regulations—this is a fact. The following statement is not an assumption; it actually happened to me.

Before delivering a package, a postal carrier can scan it. If the carrier cannot fit an item into a mailbox and decides the package should not be set outside of a house, they can and will retain the package and hold it for future delivery.

I have experienced that scenario on several different occasions. Is it supposed to happen? No, a package should only be scanned as delivered after it has definitively reached its destination.

3. The Item Was Delivered to the Wrong Address

If you use either PayPal or eBay shipping labels, this should not be the reason. However, you still have to allow for postal error. After all, no one is perfect. Usually, if this happens, you can contact the local postal service and request that they locate the package. In most instances, since opening mail that does not belong to you is illegal, improperly delivered mail will be returned to the post office.

4. The Item Was Stolen

While this is the least common reason, it does happen. If this is the case, it is still the buyer's responsibility to contact the postal service for an insurance claim. If the package was not insured, the buyer could still recover their payment via PayPal, but that is solely their responsibility. As discussed previously, once the package is in possession of the postal carrier, it is out of your control.

How to Avoid Negative eBay Feedback if a Buyer Doesn't Receive Their Package

To address the problem of possibly receiving negative feedback, consider the following options:

Option 1

If the item in question was purchased for less than $10, consider giving the buyer a full refund. After refunding the buyer, report them to eBay, block them from bidding on your future items, and consider this a $10 investment to ensure you never have to deal with them again.

Option 2

If the total cost of the item was more than $10, follow the eBay case procedure. Once the case is closed, the buyer may leave negative feedback. You can, however, dispute/report the feedback as fraudulent or inaccurate. If the buyer has few feedback ratings on their account or is a new customer, that bodes well for you, as eBay usually favors the member with the better reputation.

Be sure to report the buyer to eBay as well to help future sellers. If the buyer is questionable and receives another report in the future, eBay can go back and remove their negative feedback if they didn't already do so when you first reported it.

Mail delivery is complicated, and mistakes do get made.

Mail delivery is complicated, and mistakes do get made.

How to Address an "Item Not Received" Claim

The most important advice I can give to sellers based on my many experiences with these claims is to be unbiased. If a buyer claims that they have not received their item, but the tracking information states that it was delivered, do not jump to the conclusion that the buyer is lying.

Send a message to your buyer, provide empathy, and let them know that you will do your best to resolve this dispute for them. Inform the buyer about the actions that you will be taking, such as:

  • Notifying eBay
  • Notifying PayPal
  • Contacting their local postal carrier
  • Opening a case with the postal carrier involved

Do not give your opinion on whether you believe they are telling the truth or if the package may have been lost. This reflects doubt. If a buyer is lying, they will use any sign of doubt to prolong their claim and try to get the item for free. Be as concise as possible and use only professional etiquette to inform your buyer of the actions that will be taken.

What Final Decision Can I Expect?

As addressed earlier, you will not be required to issue a refund if you use either eBay or Paypal shipping labels. That being said, negative feedback is still a possibility.

eBay's final decision is based on their discretion. If eBay decides that the buyer is being honest about not receiving their item and/or the item in question can not be located or confirmed as delivered, eBay may rule in favor of the buyer.

This does not mean that you have to issue a refund. It only means that the case was not resolved by you, the seller, and this will be reflected in your seller statistics. If you only have one of these per month, it won't make a difference in your seller level.

Unfortunately, eBay has become a place that holds true to the age-old motto, "the customer is always right." The best thing you can do for yourself is to sweep this experience under the rug and move forward. Try not to feel cheated and realize that buyer complaints are simply a nasty but unavoidable part of having to do business online.

Every business has to deal with customer dissatisfaction. Your business cannot be the exception to the rule. Good luck!

This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.


Tara on June 19, 2020:

I just wanted to say thank you for this article. I am a relatively new seller and just received a message that an item wasn't received two days after showing it was delivered. I automatically assumed the worse but after reading your article, I realized that was the worse possible way to approach the issue. I myself have ordered an item on ebay that never showed up so why should I assume the same didn't happen to my buyer. I submitted an Online Help Request form with USPS and the buyer's going to check with her neighbor. USPS got back to me the next day and are looking into it. Fingers crossed!

John on May 22, 2019:

a lot of times it's a picking error from the Seller so make sure you check your picking slip and the stock level before accusing the customer.

nick on December 22, 2018:

You give all this info but the real truth is even if you use paypal shipping labels if thers is NO TRACKING the seller is shit out luck and the BUYERS are using this day in day out to scam sellers of items and they then you have Ebay taking the side of the BUYER and they get ther money back and the item. EBAY has become nothing more then SCAMMERS DREAM The honesty and truthfulness of people has gone out the door, this is the reality of online buying. I bet this cons would not have the guts to go into a store and walk out with a product/item in the hands with out paying for it, so yes they hide under a coat and try to walk and that is what they are doing on EBAY ther using EBAY's and PAY PAL buyer protection to SCAM

June Whittle on September 02, 2018:

All I need to know is what to do when my purchase is not received. please assist.